If you’re a homeowner in Venice, Nokomis, Englewood, or North Port thinking about selling in the next few years, you may be wondering: Should I add a pool to increase my home’s value? The short answer? Probably not.
While pools are popular in Florida and can be a selling point for some buyers, the cost to install a pool almost always outweighs the return when it comes time to sell.
🏊 What Does a Pool Actually Cost?
Installing a new inground pool in South Sarasota County typically ranges from $60,000 to $100,000+, depending on size, features, and site conditions. If you add extras like a spa, pavers, screen enclosure, or automation, the price climbs even higher.
But when it comes to resale, most sellers see only a 30% to 50% return on that investment. That means you could spend $80,000 and recover only $25,000 to $40,000 in additional value.
📉 Why Sellers Rarely Recoup the Cost
- Appraisals are conservative: Appraisers may assign a modest value to a new pool, but it won’t match your install cost.
- Not all buyers want a pool: Some see them as maintenance-heavy or a liability.
- Market expectations vary: In some neighborhoods, pools are expected. In others, they’re a nice-to-have but not essential.
❓ So When Does a Pool Add Value?
A pool may be worthwhile if:
- Most homes in your neighborhood already have one
- You plan to enjoy it for several years before selling
- You’re not adding it purely for resale purposes
If you’re planning to sell within 2 to 5 years, adding a pool strictly for marketability is almost always a losing proposition.
🏡 Alternatives That Do Boost Value
If you’re thinking about preparing your home for a future sale, consider these lower-cost improvements instead:
- Fresh interior and exterior paint
- Updated lighting and fixtures
- Decluttering and staging
- Landscaping cleanup and curb appeal
- Screened-in lanai or outdoor sitting area
These updates tend to yield a higher ROI and help your home show better in photos and showings.
🚨 Thinking About Selling in the Next Few Years?
Before investing in a major renovation like a pool, it pays to get professional advice. I offer complimentary pricing strategy consultations, including a Comparative Market Analysis (CMA) and tailored prep suggestions for your specific home and neighborhood.
Reach out to schedule a no-pressure conversation. Let’s talk about your goals and the smartest way to get your home ready to sell—whether that’s now or a few years from now.
Robin Vaccai
Broker-Owner, Beach Bay Real Estate
Serving Venice, Nokomis, Englewood & North Port (including Wellen Park)